What Happened

A methadone clinic in Mason, Ohio, agreed to pay the government $37,500 following a DEA inspection. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Ohio announced the settlement in May 2022.

The clinic, known as HOPE Center North, was operated by the Craig and Frances Lindner Center of HOPE. Methadone is a Schedule II controlled substance. According to the settlement, the DEA inspected the clinic on July 15, 2020. The inspection covered the clinic's physical and operational security measures, the controlled substance recordkeeping the law requires, its records of receipt and dispensation of methadone, and a recordkeeping accountability audit of methadone.

The settlement details seven potential recordkeeping violations. The release gives two examples: the clinic failed to provide the DEA with a biennial inventory of its controlled substances and did not keep complete and accurate inventory records, and it failed to keep accurate DEA forms evidencing the shipment and disposal of methadone from the facility. As part of the settlement the clinic agreed to comply with all controlled substance recordkeeping standards as required by law.

“sloppiness in this area can lead to the improper diversion of drugs onto the streets, which would defeat the very purpose of these clinics’ existence”

U.S. Attorney, Southern District of Ohio, quoted in the press release, May 24, 2022

What the Release Does Not Say

The release does not allege that any employee or patient diverted methadone, and it does not state a quantity of methadone that was missing. The case is a records case: the government's finding was that required inventories and DEA forms were missing or inaccurate. The release does not list the other five violations, and it does not say whether the clinic admitted liability.

Why Records Cases Matter for Diversion Control

A biennial inventory and accurate receipt and disposal forms are the baseline against which a shortage can be measured. The DEA inspection in this case included an accountability audit of methadone, which compares what the records say should be on hand with what is. Where the inventory records are incomplete or the shipment and disposal forms are inaccurate, that comparison cannot be made reliably.

  • Check that the biennial inventory exists, is dated, and is kept with the other controlled substance records. The regulatory guide sets out what the federal rules require.
  • Reconcile shipment and disposal forms against the dispensing log on a schedule, so a gap appears in months rather than at an inspection.
  • Treat the settlement terms as a model for self-audit: the clinic agreed to comply with all controlled substance recordkeeping standards, which is the standard an inspector will apply.

Related Guidance

Sources